Shortly after their arrival in Salem, Nancy Wesley brought a teenage girl named Chloe Lane (Nadia Bjorlin) to come live with her and her husband, Craig Wesley (via Soap Central). Chloe had grown up in an orphanage, and Nancy claimed she was the daughter of an old friend who needed a family of her own.

In reality, she was Nancy's long-lost daughter whom she'd given birth to as a teenager. Chloe was forced to pretend she was someone else, and Craig wasn't thrilled about having a stranger thrust into his life, which put a strain on the relationship between the two.

Eventually, Nancy admitted the truth about Chloe to her husband, and Craig was upset to learn that Nancy had apparently cheated on him back in the day since they had been together since high school. However, he had come to care for Chloe and, over time, grew to love her as his own.

Nancy decided to keep Chloe's paternity a secret, despite being pressed for information by both Craig and Chloe (via Soaps in Depth). However, after a few years, she finally revealed that she had been raped by one of her father's business associates when she was 16, resulting in her pregnancy.