Evelyn wasn't completely done with TV when her season of 90 Day Fiancé ended. Rather, the singer-songwriter reappeared on our screens just two years later as a contestant on American Idol. According to Us Weekly, Evelyn's time on the show's 2019 season was cut short when she was eliminated just prior to making it into the top 10. In her final performances, Evelyn sang "The Middle" by Jimmy Eat World and "Dust in the Wind" by Kansas. Following her departure, the songstress admitted in an Instagram post that her nerves got the best of her. She wrote, "I faltered under the stress, pressure and emotions of it all and my performance suffered."

The experience wasn't a total loss though — Evelyn's appearances on the show got the attention of Marlo Mortel, a Filipino singer-actor, and the two collaborated on a song and released a video in May 2020, according to ABS-CBN News. Evelyn also teamed up with American Idol alum Alex Preston, and she continues to release her own music on Spotify and YouTube.