In a 2016 interview with Teen Vogue, Cindy Miguens, who served as the makeup department head on "Pretty Little Liars," told the outlet, "Shay Mitchell's signature look on Pretty Little Liars is a bronze contoured and highlighted goddess." 

To achieve this effect, Miguens used Stila's "In the Light" palette for Emily's shimmery eyes, per Teen Vogue. While this palette has been discontinued, the shades are easily duped in both high-end palettes and affordable drugstore eyeshadows. Tru swapping out Stila's "Kitten" for Maybelline's 24 Hour Color Tattoo in the shade "Barely Branded." For a pop of color, Miguens used Benefit Cosmetics' "Coralista" blush and Tarte Cosmetics' "Acerola Rush" lip gloss. While both of these products have also been discontinued, dupes — such as Glossier's "Cloud Paint" in the shade "Beam" and Tarte Cosmetics' "Marajuca Juicy Lip" lip gloss collection — are everywhere! 

The last step in the iconic Emily Fields look is lots and lots of lashes. "Two things that Shay loves is to be contoured and have lots of lashes," Meguins told Teen Vogue. Meguins swears by the simple yet elegant CoverGirl LashBlast Mascara.