For the past two years, we consulted with Men's Health's Grooming editors and writers on the top winter colognes for men. Experts including our Grooming Editor, Garrett Munce, and our Deputy Editor of Commerce, Christian Gollayan, tried more than 50 men's fragrances and evaluated their ingredients, application, and just how well they smelled after a day of use. We also considered top-reviewed winter colognes that had at least 100 five-star customer ratings on e-commerce websites that we trust.